It's Not Who Comes, It's Who Stays

Michael Donovan, PhD

12/16/20256 min read

please come in signboard during daytime
please come in signboard during daytime

We live in a world obsessed with arrivals. We celebrate the new job, the new relationship, the new friend who lights up the room at the party. We post about fresh starts and exciting beginnings, carefully curating the moments when someone or something enters our life. But somewhere between the champagne toast and the morning after, we forget the most important truth: it's not who comes into your life that matters most—it's who stays.

This realization doesn't arrive dramatically. It comes quietly, usually in retrospect, when you're looking back at the landscape of your life and noticing the faces that remain. The friend who still texts you on your birthday even though you live three time zones apart. The partner who stayed through the messy middle of your transformation. The colleague who became family not because of a singular moment of connection, but because of a thousand small acts of showing up.

The Seduction of Arrival

There's something intoxicating about newness. When someone enters our life, they arrive without the weight of disappointed expectations or accumulated grievances. They haven't seen us at our worst. They don't know about our peculiar anxieties or the ways we shut down when we're afraid. They meet the version of us we present to the world, and we meet their polished exterior in return.

New relationships feel effortless because they haven't yet been tested. The coworker who joins your team brings fresh energy and ideas. The person you start dating seems to understand you perfectly during those early conversations that stretch into the early morning hours. The friend you meet at a conference feels like someone you've known forever, the conversation flowing with an ease that feels almost destined.

We make the mistake of thinking this ease is the relationship itself, when really it's just the honeymoon phase of any connection. Arrival is easy. Staying is the art form.

The Unglamorous Work of Staying

Staying means being there for the 3 AM phone call when someone's world is falling apart and you have work in the morning. It means having the same argument for the fifth time and still choosing to work through it rather than walking away. It means witnessing someone's growth, including the awkward and painful parts, and not using their past mistakes as ammunition forever.

Staying is showing up to the hospital room. It's remembering someone's coffee order after years of friendship. It's sending the article you know they'd find interesting even though you haven't talked in a month. It's choosing them again and again, not in grand romantic gestures, but in the daily decision to remain present and engaged.

The people who stay are the ones who see you fail and don't turn away. They watch you make poor decisions, and instead of abandoning you, they help you pick up the pieces while being honest about what you could have done differently. They witness your success without letting envy poison the relationship. They hold space for your contradictions—the fact that you can be both generous and selfish, confident and insecure, loving and infuriating.

When Staying Becomes Choosing

There's a crucial distinction to make here: staying isn't the same as remaining out of obligation or fear. Some people stay in our lives long past the expiration date of the relationship, held in place by guilt, history, or the sunk cost fallacy. That's not the kind of staying that matters.

The staying that transforms lives is active, not passive. It's a choice made repeatedly, sometimes daily. It's the difference between someone who is merely present and someone who is truly there. You can share a house with someone and not stay in their life in any meaningful way. You can work alongside someone for years and never really show up for them.

The people who stay choose to stay. They've seen what else is out there, they know your flaws and limitations, and they've decided that this relationship—with you, specifically—is worth the continued investment. That kind of staying is a gift.

The Painful Truth About Departures

Understanding that staying matters more than arriving also means accepting that many people won't stay, and that's not always a reflection of your worth. People leave for countless reasons. Sometimes the timing is wrong. Sometimes they're on a different path. Sometimes the relationship served its purpose for a season and naturally concluded. Sometimes people are doing their own work of learning who deserves their presence, and you're not on that list.

This can be agonizing, especially when someone who arrived with fireworks leaves quietly, or worse, abruptly. The friend who ghosted you after you were vulnerable. The mentor who moved on to the next protégé. The romantic partner who seemed perfect until the reality of your actual life together set in.

But here's what I've learned: when someone chooses not to stay, they're actually doing you a favor, even if it doesn't feel that way. They're making space for the people who will stay. They're clarifying the landscape of your life, helping you understand who your true companions are. A person who leaves—especially one who leaves when things get difficult—is showing you they weren't going to be there for the journey ahead. Better to know now than to rely on someone who will eventually disappoint you at a more crucial moment.

The People Who Stay Become Family

Blood family is the family you're born into. Chosen family is made up of the people who stay. These are the relationships that define the quality of your life. They're the ones you call when you get good news, not because you're obligated to, but because the joy isn't complete until you've shared it with them. They're the ones whose opinion actually matters when you're making a big decision. They're the ones who know your history well enough to provide context when you're spiraling.

The beautiful thing about the people who stay is that the relationship deepens in ways that no new connection can replicate. There's a wealth of shared experience, inside jokes, mutual understanding, and built trust. They know the long version of your stories. They remember who you were before this version of yourself, and they can reflect back to you how far you've come.

This kind of relationship can't be rushed or manufactured. It requires time and consistency. It requires weathering storms together. It requires both people committing to the ongoing work of maintaining the connection even when it's inconvenient or difficult.

How to Become Someone Who Stays

If staying matters more than arriving, then perhaps we should all aspire to be the kind of people who stay in others' lives. This doesn't mean staying in every relationship or never setting boundaries—healthy endings are sometimes necessary. It means developing the capacity for loyalty, consistency, and long-term commitment.

  • Become someone who remembers. Not just birthdays and anniversaries, but the details of people's lives. Their struggles, their dreams, the thing they mentioned they were worried about last month. Remembering is an act of love that says "you matter enough for me to hold space in my mind for your life."

  • Become someone who shows up, even when it's inconvenient. Especially when it's inconvenient. The measure of a relationship isn't how you act when it's easy, but whether you're there when your presence requires sacrifice. This might mean rearranging your schedule, having difficult conversations, or simply being present when you'd rather be doing something else.

  • Become someone who grows alongside people rather than outgrowing them. Yes, some relationships end because people change in incompatible ways, but many relationships end simply because someone decided the other person wasn't "on their level" anymore. Humility and loyalty often matter more than achievement when it comes to sustaining relationships.

  • Become someone who forgives and allows for forgiveness. Every long-term relationship will involve harm, disappointment, and misunderstanding. The people who stay are the ones who can navigate repair, who can apologize sincerely and accept apologies gracefully, who understand that loving someone means accepting their full humanity, flaws included.

The Quiet Power of Presence

In a culture that celebrates novelty and the next big thing, choosing to stay is almost revolutionary. It's a rejection of the idea that we should constantly be upgrading our relationships, trading in the old model for something newer and shinier. It's a commitment to depth over breadth, to quality over quantity.

The people who stay in your life are the ones writing the story of who you really are. They're the witnesses to your becoming. They hold the institutional memory of your journey. When you're old and looking back, it won't be the people who passed through that you remember most vividly—it will be the ones who remained.

So pay attention to who stays. Thank them. Honor them. And maybe most importantly, be intentional about becoming someone who stays in the lives of the people you love. Because at the end of the day, it's not the crowd at your party that matters—it's who's still there helping you clean up after everyone else has gone home.

That's where real life happens. That's where real love is built. Not in the arrival, but in the staying.